This nuance is crucial. The same piece of code looks different depending on how it’s used: a tool that helps an abandoned game run on modern systems is hardly villainous; a tool that distributes paid DLC without permission is another matter. Community norms often try to self-police this line—many modders explicitly avoid distributing proprietary files or encourage users to provide their own legitimately obtained data. The tension persists because the underlying question—who controls a purchased but ephemeral digital object?—remains unresolved.